Identification and comparison of Xanthium Strumarium as crime scene evidence in forensic rape case by maceration and ED-XRF techniques
- 1Regional Forensic Science Laboratory, Opposite Vidyut Nagar, Dindori Road Nashik-422004, Maharashtra, India
- 2Dept. of Botany, K.R.T. Arts, B.H. Commerce and A.M. Science College Shivajinagar, Gangapur Road, Nashik-422002, Maharashtra, India
- 3Dept. of Botany, K.R.T. Arts, B.H. Commerce and A.M. Science College Shivajinagar, Gangapur Road, Nashik-422002, Maharashtra, India
- 4Regional Forensic Science Laboratory, Opposite Vidyut Nagar, Dindori Road Nashik-422004, Maharashtra, India
- 5Regional Forensic Science Laboratory, Opposite Vidyut Nagar, Dindori Road Nashik-422004, Maharashtra, India
- 6Regional Forensic Science Laboratory, Opposite Vidyut Nagar, Dindori Road Nashik-422004, Maharashtra, India
- 7Regional Forensic Science Laboratory, Opposite Vidyut Nagar, Dindori Road Nashik-422004, Maharashtra, India
- 8Directorate of Forensic Science Laboratories, Vidhyanagari, Kaliana, Mumbai-400098, Maharashtra, India
Res. J. Forensic Sci., Volume 5, Issue (1), Pages 1-8, July,29 (2017)
Forensic botany is utilization of plant materials in crime investigation and court. It utilizes traces of plant material as physical aid for criminal investigations. The physical aids found at the crime scene can throw light in determining circumstances happened at the crime scene. The physical clues left therefore decides whether victim was (and was not) involved at the crime scene. These types of cluesare challenges for forensic experts to collect evidences and make analysis from crime scenarios. As rape is a contact crime. Herein we report a forensic rape case in which the weed material of Xanthium Strumarium L. adhere on accused cloths and victim cloths and the weed material of Xanthium Strumarium collected from crime scenario all of them belongs to same plants materials. First we performed the physical fit of half of the weed piece observed on accused cloths and another half part of weed observed on victim cloths matched exactly with each other. A small quantity of macerated tissues may be mounted in glycerin and observed under microscope. The ED-XRF spectrometry is suitable analytical tool to detect the trace elements presents in all the samples of weed of Xanthium Strumarium L. A single weed material of Xanthium Strumarium L. provided link between the criminal, the victim and the scene of occurrence.
- SFED (2007)., Shorter Oxford English Dictionary., (6th ed.), Oxford University Press, ISBN 978-0-19-920687-2
- Gordh Gordon and Headrick D.H. (2001)., A Dictionary of Entomology., Cambridge, MA: CABI Publishing. ISBN 978-0-85199-291-4.
- Boyd A.E. (2006)., Plants and perpetrators: forensic investigation in the botany classroom., American Biology Teacher, 68(9), 145-147.
- Coyle H.M. (2005)., Forensic Botany: Principles and Applications to Criminal Casework., Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
- Dickison W.C. (2000)., Integrative Plant Anatomy., San Diego, CA: Harcourt Academic Press, 399-419.
- Dilcher D.L. (2001)., Forensic botany: case studies in the use of plant anatomy., Phytomorphology, 51(3-4), 181-184.
- Entwistle T. (2003)., Silent winess., Nature Australia, 27, 76-77. Graham S. (2006).
- Agharkar S.P. (1953)., Medicinal plants of Bombay presidency., Scientific Publishers, Jodhpur (India). 188-189.
- Oudhia P. (2001)., Phyto-sociological studies of rainy season wasteland weeds with special reference to Partheniumhysterophorus L., Raipur (India) district. Asian J. Microbiol. Biotech. Environ. Sci., 3(1-2), 89-92.
- Oudhia P. and Dixit A. (1994)., Weeds in Ambimkapur region (Madhya Pradesh) and their traditional use., Weed News., 1(2), 19-21.
- Caius J.F. (1986)., Medicinal and poisonous plants of India., Scientific Publishers, Jodhpur (India), 375-376.
- (a) Holm L.G., Donald P., Pancho J.V. and Herberger J.P. (1977)., The World, The University Press of Hawaii, Honolulu, Hawaii. (b) Oudhia P., Pandey N. and Tripathi R.S. (1998).
- Wheeler E.A. and Baas P. (1998)., Wood identification: A review.
- (a) Kirk P.L. (1953)., Crime Investigation: Physical Evidence And The Police Laboratory., Interscience Publishers, Inc.: New York, 22, 784. (b) Chisum W.J. and Turvey B. (2000).
- (a) MHA (2011)., Ministry of Home Affairs., National Crime Records Bureau, Crime in India, 79. (b) IE (1872).
- Teresa MagalhaesRicardo, Jorge Dinis-Oliveira, Benedita Silva, Francisco Corte-Real and Duarte Nuno Vieira (2015)., Biological Evidence Management for DNA Analysis in Cases of Sexual Assault., The Scientific World Journal, Article ID 365674, 1-11
- MWCD (2012)., Ministry of Woman and Child development., Model Guidelines under Section 39 of The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act.
- PCSO (2012)., The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 Kerala Medico-legal Society., https://sites.google.com/site/keralamedicolegalsociety/home-1/important-laws-and-rules/pcasa-act-2012-1/html
- Bagadia V.N, Bhat Radha, Ghadiali H.H, Pradhan P.V. and Shah L.P. (1976)., A Comparative Double - Blind Trial OfPimozide And Trifluoperzine In Maintenance Treatment Of Schizophrenia., Indian J Psychiatry, 18(3), 199-203.
- Naik V.N. (1998)., Flora of Marathwada., Amrut Prakashan, Aurangabad, India, 2.
- Bethune Sherry (2007)., The forensic Evaluation of Fracture Marks: a Validation and Experimental study., 2007.
- Shashank Mahesh, Kumar Pramod and Ansari S.A. (2015)., A rapid and economical method for the maceration of wood fibers in Boswellia serrata Roxb., Tropical Plant Research, 2(2), 108-111.
- Hall R., Patton B.D. and Haas P.A. (1986)., Reaction of formaldehyde and nitric acid in a remotely operated thermo siphon evaporator., Proceedings of Waste Management
- Han James S., Mianowski Theodore and Lin Yi-yu (1999)., Validity of plant fiber length measurement: a review of fiber length measurement based on kenaf as a model., Mississippi State, Mississippi State University, Ag & Bio Engineering, 149-167.
- Jeffrey E.C. (1917)., The anatomy of woody plants., University of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois.
- Kwiatek W.M., Kubica B., Paluszkiewicz C. and Galka M. (2001)., Trace elements analysis by means of synchroton radiation, XRF, and PIXE: Selection of sample preparation produce., J. Alloys Compd., 328, 283-288.
- Yeung Z.L.L., Kwok R.C.W. and Yu K.N. (2003)., Determination of multi-element profiles of street dust using energy dispersive X-ray fluorescence (EDXRF)., Appl. Radiat. Isot., 58, 339-346.
- Ekinci N., Budak G. and Karabulut A. (2002)., Energy dispersive X-ray fluorescence spectrometry in the detection of Ikizdere ore concentrates., J. Quant. Spectrosc. Radiat. Transfer, 75(3), 351-356.